Restaurant Menu 5 · 16 reviews $1–10
High Point Creamery Menu
Colorado, United States
Menu last updated: Jun 25, 2026
Explore High Point Creamery's ice cream menu in Fort Collins, CO. Casual dessert options including pints, sorbets, and sundaes from $1–10. Check menu details on Locallya..
Restaurant
High Point Creamery
Cuisine
Restaurant
Location
Colorado
Price
$1–10
Rating
5 / 5
Full menu
Full Menu
Browse the complete High Point Creamery menu with current prices and options.
Main Menu
-
Orange & Olive Oil (Pint)
$9.99Bright citrus with a silky finish. Vibrant orange paired with lush olive oil for a smooth, lightly savory ice cream that’s fresh, elegant, and perfectly balanced.
-
8 Oz Hand Burned Caramel Sauce
$9.99We use a combination of brown and cane sugar to get the full sugar notes. We then burn the sugar and slowly add in cream to create our luscious caramel sauce. Drizzle it on our ice creams- or just use a spoon, it's sooo good!
-
Pint Of Mint Chocolate Bark
$9.99This shows what we do best… a pound of fresh mint: torn, steeped, and strained; hand-shaved Belgium milk chocolate; and fresh, Colorado cream all combine for an unparalleled explosion of fresh ingredients and uncompromised quality.
-
Pint Of Tiramisu
$9.99Espresso-soaked ladyfingers, mascarpone cream, and a dusting of cocoa folded into rich ice cream for a decadent twist on the classic Italian dessert.
-
Pint Of Cherry Miso
$9.99This cherry ice cream balances bright, fruity sweetness with an unexpected savory twist. Studded with small chunks of miso, it finishes with a subtle salty depth that makes the cherry flavor pop and keeps each bite interesting.
-
Soft Cheese W/Red Pepper Jelly (Pint)
$9.99Sweet heat meets creamy indulgence. Bright red pepper jelly swirled through tangy cream cheese ice cream, inspired by classic charcuterie boards and that perfect sweet-savory bite.
-
Pint Of Brown Butter Pecan
$9.99Our take on the classic butter pecan ice cream. Beurre Noisette (ooh la la) is the flavor profile we try to match. Browning butter imparts a rich, nutty flavor to the cream. Pecans are double toasted in our ovens to prevent the pecans from getting soggy as they are suspended in the cream.
-
Pint Of Dark Chocolate Orange Marshmallows
$9.99A High Point Creamery holiday tradition and back by popular demand. Inspired by chocolate covered oranges that come in your stocking at Christmas (unless you're naughty).
-
Pint Of Huckleberry Lime Sorbet
$9.99Sweet huckleberries and zesty lime come together for a crisp, jewel-toned sorbet that’s as refreshing as a cool fall breeze.
-
Pint Of Cookies (Three Ways) & Cream
$9.99Always looking to uplevel, we add three house-made cookies - butter, chocolate chip, and chocolate wafer cookies - all swirled through a vanilla icing ice cream. Seriously, this is the best Cookies & Cream you've ever had.
-
Cookies & Cream Sandwich
$8.99Indulge in the artistry of crafting our delectable ice cream sandwiches. We skillfully fashion a cake-like sugar cookie base, meticulously designed to enhance the ice cream experience.
-
Pint Of Coconut Creme Brulee (Vegan)
$9.99Creamy coconut with pops of house-made brûlée chips are the primary characteristics of this vegan delight.
-
Tahitian Vanilla Sandwich
$8.99Indulge in the artistry of crafting our delectable ice cream sandwiches. We skillfully fashion a cake-like sugar cookie base, meticulously designed to enhance the ice cream experience.
-
Pint Of Peppermint
$9.99Peppermint, Peppermint and MORE Peppermint! We add peppermint extract to our Royal Crest Cream, freeze it and then sprinkle in peppermint candies into the ice cream.
-
Pint Of Coffee Bean
$9.99Denver's own Novo Coffee is ground and steeped overnight in our fresh Colorado cream. The resulting concoction contains all of the bright coffee flavor but none of the bitter. One of our quiet standouts.
-
Watermelon & Tajin Sorbet (Pint)
$9.99This is a super refreshing sorbet made with just fruit and fruit juice—no water, no dairy. It’s all watermelon, with a little Tajín for a spicy, tangy kick at the end. It tastes like a chilled slice of watermelon with chili-lime salt at a backyard party.
-
Honey Butter Biscuit (Pint)
$9.99Warm, comforting, and a little indulgent.
-
Pint Of Mango Sorbet
$9.99This bright, tropical sorbet is made with real mango juice—no water, no fillers, just pure fruit flavor. It’s sweet, smooth, and tastes like a perfectly ripe mango straight off the tree.
-
Pint Of Salted Caramel
$9.99Those burns on our kitchen staff? Salted. Freaking. Caramel. Sugar is melted in our kettle until it pillows up and reaches the perfect temperature. Smoking and scorching is all part of the process in making this delicious sweet and salty confection. We then slowly add cream and carefully mix it into the boiling sugar, creating one of our most popular flavors.
-
Pint Of Joan's Pumpkin Pie
$9.99Erika’s mom’s beloved chiffon-style pumpkin pie, folded into creamy ice cream with our house-made graham cracker crust for a cozy taste of fall.
-
Pint Of Bavarian Cream Pie
$9.99Indulge in the luscious Bavarian cream ice cream, reminiscent of a rich custard and added in the graham cracker crust you know and love from Pumpkin Pie
-
Pint Of Salty Dog Chocolate
$9.99This started out as a mistake when a prep chef used tablespoons instead of teaspoons of salt. However, it turned out to be a delicious mistake. A medium-bodied chocolate that tastes like a brownie batter. Erika told them to "throw it into the dipping cabinet, call it Salty Dog Chocolate, and let's see what happens." It continues to be our most popular flavor.
-
Pint Of Peach Sorbet
$9.99Juicy, sun-ripened peaches blended into a silky, vibrant sorbet for a bright taste of late harvest sweetness.
-
Pina Colada Sorbet (Pint)
$9.99Bright, tropical, and super refreshing. This Sorbet will have you thinking you're on the beach.
-
Pint Of Milk Chocolate
$9.99Belgium chocolate and Colorado cream took a walk down by the Arkansas. The result? Beautiful, velvety milk chocolate ice cream.
-
Pint Of Basil With Blackberry Swirl
$9.99Our signature flavor... a pound of fresh basil is cleaned, torn, and steeped overnight in our local cream. Like a tea, we strain the basil out and swirl in our house-made blackberry sauce... a balance of earth and sweet. Fresh ingredients make this innovative flavor a surprising treat.
-
Pint Of Tin Cup Whiskey With Pistachio Brittle
$9.99Colorado’s own Tin Cup Whiskey is added to our sweet cream, and if that wasn't enough, this amazing ice cream is then studded with "from scratch" pistachio brittle chopped throughout. Sweet, salty, nutty... this flavor has it all.
-
House Made Waffle Cones
$2.00The reason our shops smell so good? Waffle Cones, handmade every day!
-
4 Pack Of Sugar Cones
$2.00Four pack of sugar cones, make your own scoops at home!
-
Violet & Lime (Pint)
$9.99Delicate floral violet balanced with a bright splash of lime. Light, aromatic, and refreshingly tart, this ice cream is elegant, crisp, and unexpectedly addictive.
-
2 Oz Sprinkles
$2.00Bring a little added extra JOY to your ice cream, go ahead and make it a party!
-
Pint Of Brown Sugar Cinnamon
$9.99Warm and inviting... we've added Red Ape cinnamon and the perfect amount of brown sugar to create an amazing blend. You may want to spread this on toast or a cake, but you can just eat it with a spoon.
-
Pint Of Simply Strawberry
$9.99Fresh strawberries are macerated overnight to help draw out their sweetness. The strawberries are then blended into our gorgeous Colorado cream.
-
Pint Of Tahitian Vanilla
$9.99Aromatic vanilla beans combine with fresh sweet cream to create a joyful and bright Vanilla Bean ice cream.
-
Pint Of Funfetti
$9.99It's Back! Our house-made Funfetti Cake (Birthday Cake with Sprinkles) in an icing ice cream
-
Pint Of Pomegranate Lime Sorbet
$9.99Our Pomegranate Lime Sorbet is a refreshing and tangy blend of juicy pomegranate and zesty lime. Its vibrant, tart flavors are perfectly balanced for a light, crisp, and invigorating treat that's both sweet and citrusy. A deliciously cool burst of fruit in every spoonful!
-
Pint Of Earl Grey With Shortbread Cookies
$9.99t's like having high tea with the Queen. Hints of bergamot orange give way to the lavishness of our cream. This ice cream has been featured on the Cooking Channel's "Unique Sweets."
-
Lavender Lemonade Sorbet (Pint)
$9.99This Lavender Lemonade Sorbet is a refreshing and sophisticated dessert that's perfect for anyone who loves the bright and tangy flavors of lemon and the delicate sweetness of lavender. The combination of these two flavors creates a perfect balance of tartness and sweetness.
-
Pint Of Blueberry Lemon
$9.99Five pounds of perfectly ripe blueberries go into every batch of this crowd pleaser, and a touch of tart lemons complete this oh-so-yummy ice cream.
-
Brown Sugar Cinnamon Sandwich
$8.99Indulge in the artistry of crafting our delectable ice cream sandwiches. We skillfully fashion a cake-like sugar cookie base, meticulously designed to enhance the ice cream experience.
-
Spicy Brownies (Pint)
$9.99Creamy milk chocolate ice cream with chunks of homemade brownies—each one bringing a surprise kick of chipotle to keep things interesting. It’s sweet, it’s spicy, and it’s got just enough sass to keep you coming back for more.
-
4 Pack Of Cake Cones
$2.004 pack of cake cones, go ahead and make scoops at home!
-
The Sundae Kit
$25.00* Ice cream not included* Want to make your own Sundaes at home? We've done the leg work for you! Four sugar cones, roasted pecans, marshmallows, sprinkles and cherries. But let's not forget about the stars of our kit- our amazing hand burnt caramel and hand crafted fudge sauces are included. That's 8 oz of our award winning, decadent sauces! Add on two pints for a happy dance that serves four people.
-
Pint Of Banana Matcha
$9.99The whitest white girl flavor we’ve ever made (and it’s delicious). Creamy banana meets earthy matcha for a smooth, vibrant scoop you didn’t know you needed.
-
Pint Of Rum Raisin
$9.99This one’s a classic! We soak the raisins in real rum so they get all plump and flavorful, and then mix them into a brown sugar cinnamon base. It’s smooth and rich, with that little burst of warm, boozy raisin in each bite.
-
Cornbread With Strawberry Jam
$9.99Buttermilk ice cream spotted with house-made cornbread and a fresh strawberry jam.
Dietary & food tags
What this menu is great for
Food & Dietary Tags
Dessert Quick bite Ice cream shop $1–10 Price Range Good for kids Solo dining Wheelchair accessible Delivery & Takeout Casual atmosphere
Dietary and allergen information may vary by item and should be confirmed with the restaurant.
Plan a visit
Visiting High Point Creamery
Open daily from noon with extended hours on weekends. Offers dine-in, takeout, delivery, and no-contact delivery. Located with free parking and wheelchair accessible entry.
1208 W Elizabeth St #120W, Fort Collins, CO 80521, United StatesToday at High Point Creamery
- Opens at 12:00 PM
- +1 720-805-0077
- No-contact delivery · Delivery · Onsite services · Takeout · Dine-in
- Credit cards · Debit cards
About the menu
About the High Point Creamery Menu
Ice cream & sorbet focus Main Menu section Affordable pricing ($1–10) Family friendly with casual atmosphere Convenient Fort Collins location
The menu features a variety of artisan ice cream pints, sorbets, and sundae kits designed for quick dessert enjoyment.
Popular offerings include unique flavors such as Basil With Blackberry Swirl, Brown Sugar Cinnamon, and Coconut Creme Brulee (vegan). The Main Menu also includes specialty items like cookies & cream sandwiches and sugar cones.
Options support onsite dining, takeout, and delivery, accommodating different visit preferences throughout the week.
Menu items and prices may change; availability depends on the day and season.
The menu offers pints of ice cream and sorbet, sundae kits, and ice cream sandwiches, all found in the Main Menu section.
Yes, the Pint Of Coconut Creme Brulee is labeled as vegan among the Main Menu items.
Visitors can choose dine-in, takeout, delivery, or no-contact delivery for convenience.
Free parking is available in the lot adjacent to the restaurant.
The restaurant provides a wheelchair accessible entrance, parking, and seating.
Menu items generally range from $1 to $10, suitable for a quick dessert.
While popularity varies, flavors like Basil With Blackberry Swirl, Brown Sugar Cinnamon, and Mango Sorbet receive positive mentions.
More menus to browse
Similar restaurants with menus
Other Restaurant in Colorado with menus on Locallya.
Restaurant
Restoran shabicknoor Menu
42, Jalan Uda Utama, Bandar Uda Utama, 81200 Johor Bahru, Johor Darul Ta'zim, Malaysia
3.5 View Menu
Pizza Restaurant
Pizzeria Il Ritrovo Menu
Hauptstraße 12, 93349 Mindelstetten, Germany
4.3 View Menu
Cafe
Wallis’ Caff Menu
Admin block, Bessemer market, Bessemer Rd, Cardiff CF11 8BA, United Kingdom
4.6 View Menu
For business owners
Own or manage this restaurant?
Help customers find the latest menu by updating dishes, prices, photos, and availability. Keep your High Point Creamery listing accurate on Locallya.
- Free to claim & verify
- Edit menu items anytime
- Update prices & photos
- Respond to customer reviews